People call and say, just quote me a rate.

We still ask for last month’s statement. That is not us stalling. It is how we stay upfront and honest.

A lot of owners think they already know the number. They’ll tell you they are at 2.5%. Or 2%. Or 1.5%. One clean rate, end of story.

Open the statement and that number is almost never the whole story. Most processors hide cost in a few different places on the same bill. If you only look at the rate they quoted you, you miss it.

So we break down every line. You see, to the penny, what you paid last month.

Then we do a little time-machine test. If you had processed that same month with us, what would you have paid? That comparison is to the penny too. You would have saved X amount.

X is blank on purpose. We do not invent it on a call. We fill it in after we see your statement.

That is why we want at least one full month. It is the only way to give you a true apples-to-apples look.

Start with volume, not the flashy rate on page one

The first thing we look at is volume. How much did you run last month?

Then we look at the mix. How much of that was Visa, Mastercard, American Express, and Discover. Different cards cost different amounts, so the mix matters more than the cover rate.

We do not lean on the rate printed on page one. People in this business call that the discount rate.

That is where a processor likes to put a flashy low number. It looks great in a quote. You almost never actually get it.

Calculate your effective processing rate

The quoted rate is one number. Your effective rate shows what the whole bill cost against the card volume you processed.

Effective processing rate = total card-processing fees ÷ gross card sales × 100.

For example, $2,800 in fees on $100,000 in card sales is a 2.8% effective rate. That is an illustration, not a target rate or a savings promise.

Use fees and card sales from the same period. Include fees deducted from daily deposits and fees collected separately at month-end, but do not count the same charge twice. Add separately billed gateway or processing charges so they do not disappear from the comparison.

Use card sales, not total business revenue or the net deposit that reached your bank. Refund amounts, chargeback amounts and reserves affect deposits, but those amounts are not processing fees. Identify any associated fees separately.

If a billback relates to an earlier month, identify that before comparing providers. Show annual fees and one-time equipment costs separately, too. Card mix, ticket size and how you accept payments help explain why the effective rate changes.

What page one leaves out

The cover rate leaves out the extras. Those extras are where the real bill lives.

Some cards cost the processor more than that flashy rate. They come back later and bill you the difference. That extra bill is a billback.

A downgrade happens when a transaction does not meet the requirements for a particular interchange category. A rewards or commercial card can also carry a higher underlying cost without being a downgrade. Ask which category applied and why before treating the whole difference as processor markup.

The card brands also charge their own fees on top. You will see them as network fees, association fees, or assessments. They are easy to skip if you only read page one.

Monthly fees get stacked on after the rate.

Add those up and it does not come out to the number on the cover. Then we look at the real pile of fees (the discount total) and which pricing program you are on.

You might be on one of five setups

How you are priced changes what the statement can even tell us. Same shop, different program, different story.

Interchange pass-through. The processor shows the card-brand cost and their markup. We can see the cards and the mix. This one is apples to apples.

Flat rate. One rate, usually plus a small fee every time a card is run. Simple to quote. The statement often hides the card-brand categories, so we have to guess some of the mix. We tell you when we are guessing.

Two-tier. A “qualified” rate and a “non-qualified” rate. A lot of cards miss the cheap bucket.

Three-tier. Qualified, mid-qualified, and non-qualified. Same idea, one more bucket.

Billback. A processor initially charges a quoted rate, then bills additional transaction costs later. Match those adjustments to the original processing period and ask what is underlying cost versus processor markup.

We walk the statement until we know what you actually paid. Not what the quote said.

Recurring fees to check

PCI fees, batch fees and statement fees can add up. Check what each charge covers and whether the service is useful for your business. The fee name alone does not tell you whether the amount is reasonable.

PCI DSS is the payment-card security standard. Your business still has responsibilities even when a processor handles the payments. Ask which requirements apply to your setup, how you must validate compliance, and what help the processor actually provides.

A PCI fee does not make you compliant. A non-compliance fee does not replace the work, either. We check what each charge covers, what your agreement says, and whether you are paying for support you are not receiving.

Billing schedules and funding fees

Check whether fees are deducted from each deposit or billed separately at month-end. If your agreement charges differently for those options, include that cost in the comparison.

Next-day funding is available with some setups, but it is not universal. Batch cutoff times, weekends, holidays, your bank and account reviews can affect when money becomes available. Ask whether a faster-funding fee is optional, what timing it buys, and whether that timing applies to your account.

Also ask which costs are passed through and which include processor markup. Compare the complete monthly cost rather than one fee in isolation.

A “good rate” on a quote usually misses your card mix

Here is the trick. A “good rate” on a quote is only as honest as the program behind it.

If you are on interchange pass-through, we know how you take cards and what the mix is. The comparison is exact.

If you are on a flat rate, we cannot see every card category. We tell you we are making conservative guesses. We would rather guess low and be clear about it than promise a number we cannot see.

Here is an example. It is not a guarantee.

Say you process $100,000 a month at a 4% flat rate. We use what we know about an industry’s mix. Debit versus credit. The cheap debit cards that get a capped rate. Corporate cards, business cards, rewards cards.

Then we give a reasonable, conservative guess of the monthly savings.

That is a guess until we have the statement. It is not a promised percent. Your mix is the thing that makes the math real.

What to send us

Whether you are in Kansas City or not, we work with merchants across the country.

Send one month’s statement.

We will break it down. We will show you the fees. We will tell you if they are already fair. If they are, we will say so. That is a useful answer too.

If we cannot save you on the fees on that statement, we will cut you a check for $5,000. We are that confident.

Send a statement through our upload form. Use one combined PDF for a multi-page statement. Or email us to request a secure upload link. Do not include customer card numbers or security codes.

That is the whole first step.

Sources and related guides

For the underlying requirements, see PCI SSC on merchant responsibilities, Mastercard on interchange and qualification, and Chase’s examples of funding conditions. Funding terms differ by provider and account.

For practical applications, read our guides to dealership processing, virtual terminal and invoice payments, and dual pricing versus surcharging.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Curious what you could save?

Send one month’s statement. We’ll work up a free savings analysis.

Or call (877) 737-3344

24/7/365 Customer Service: (877) 737-3344

 

Empower Payments is a registered ISO of Fifth Third Bank, N.A., Cincinnati, OH.